Conversion audit for lisaslobby.com

Shopify 56 checks · 4 pages

Money’s leaking
39 points short of a great score (85+)

Lovely shelves, but the till is far too quiet

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Lisa's Lobby scores 46 out of 100, and that is tough love territory. Right now the store leaks money in two places: product pages that leave shoppers unsure, and a cart that lets small orders walk out the door. With about 730 products, that gap adds up fast. The three biggest fixes below change that picture.

I picked the 5 fixes that matter most. The 3 biggest are in my guide. Fixes 4 and 5 I’ll show you right here, for free.

Tony found 18 problems

Tony went through lisaslobby.com like a customer would and ran 56 checks on 4 pages.

Visitors

How many people come to the store, by Google's data

1 problem here is part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

First impression

Across the whole store: trust, contacts, speed

  • Is a phone number or email visible in the header or footer? Serious

    No phone number or email address is shown in the header or footer.

  • Does the main content appear within 2.5 seconds on a phone? Serious

    Google's test on a typical phone (product page): the main content appears after 7.5 s (goal: under 2.5 s). For your developer: Render-blocking requests.

Category page

Gifts Under £10 – Toys & Kids' Gifts | Lisa's Lobby

lisaslobby.com/collections/gifts-under-10
  • Is product stock availability visible in the product listing? Serious

    The listing shows product names and prices, but no stock status for individual products.

  • Is the category product list sorted by default by popularity, recommendation, or best sellers? Serious

    No sort order is visible on the category page.

  • Is there a filter for discounted products available? Serious

    The available filter groups are Availability and Price; no discount filter is shown.

  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under the header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb navigation is visible between the header and category content.

Product page

Hot Wheels Nissan Skyline 2000GT-R LBWK Die-Cast Car | Lisa's Lobby

lisaslobby.com/products/mattel-hot-wheels-nissan-skyline-2000gt-r-lbwk
  • Is return policy short info available? Serious

    A refund-policy link is present, but no return information is stated on the page.

  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb navigation is shown below the header.

  • Are product reviews and ratings present? (Warning)

    The product review widget shows no customer review or product rating.

  • Is a concrete delivery date promised? (Warning)

    The timeframe refers to store pickup readiness, not delivery.

3 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Checkout

Cart and checkout, with a real product in the cart

lisaslobby.com/cart
  • Is a checkout progress indicator visible? (Warning)

    No step tracker was visible in checkout.

  • Does the form validate in real time and show clear error messages? (Warning)

    Invalid email showed no visible live error.

2 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

How to fix it

The 3 biggest problems are in Tony’s guide. Fixes 4 and 5 are open below, for free.

  1. The biggest problem

    Fix #1 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Visitors

    Show the problem and the fix
  2. The second biggest problem

    Fix #2 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Product page

    Show the problem and the fix
  3. The third biggest problem

    Fix #3 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Smaller problem Big impact Checkout

    Show the problem and the fix
  4. 4. Delivery, returns and contact in sight

    Free Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 45 minutes 0/7

    “On your Hot Wheels Nissan Skyline 2000GT-R LBWK page, the only timing a shopper sees is "Usually ready in 24 hours", and that's about pickup, not delivery. Returns are just a Refund Policy link. The Judge.me review box sits there with no rating in it, and there's no email or phone number anywhere in your header or footer. Your homepage trust section already says orders go out in 1–3 business days with 3–5 days UK delivery. But a gift buyer who lands straight on a £3.99 car never sees that, so they wonder whether it arrives in time and who they'd even ask, and then they close the tab. Today you put delivery and returns right under Add to cart, put your email in the footer and get past buyers rating what they bought.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You can do it yourself
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In your admin, click:Settings › Policies

      Open your return and refund policy and write down how many days customers get to send things back and who pays the return postage. Those facts go into the line under Add to cart, so the product page never promises more than the policy does.

      Adding store policiesShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Settings › General

      In Store contact details, make sure the store email is an inbox you actually read every day. Your automated policies use that address too. Copy it, because it goes into the footer in step 5.

      Managing store detailsShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme

      In the theme editor, use the Home page drop-down to switch to the product template, then preview the Hot Wheels Nissan Skyline page. Hover over the product information section, click Add block, pick a text block and drag it to sit right under the Add to cart button.

      Sections and blocksShopify Help Center
    5. Paste the delivery line and the returns line from below into that block, and fill in the brackets from your policy. They'll sit next to the pickup note, so shoppers see real delivery times, not just pickup. Click Save, and the block will then show on every product that uses this template.

    6. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme

      Still in the theme editor, expand the Footer area, click Add block and choose a text block if your theme offers one. Paste the contact line from below and save, then check it shows at the bottom of the homepage and the product page.

      Customizing sectionsShopify Help Center
    7. Judge.me already runs on your store, but your Hot Wheels page has no rating yet. Open Judge.me from your apps and make sure automatic review request emails go out after an order is fulfilled. The free plan covers unlimited reviews, and automatic reminders come with the $15/month plan.

      Judge.me Product Reviews AppShopify Help Center

    Ready to paste: Product page text block under Add to cart (delivery line)

    Dispatched in 1–3 business days. UK delivery 3–5 business days after dispatch, from £3.75 – free on orders £45+.

    Ready to paste: Same product page text block, second line (returns)

    Changed your mind? Send it back within [number of days] days of delivery. Full details in our Refund Policy.

    Ready to paste: Footer text block (contact)

    Questions about your order? Email Lisa at [your store email] or use the chat bubble. We usually reply within [reply time].

    How you’ll know it worked

    Open the Hot Wheels Nissan Skyline page on your phone. You should see the delivery and returns lines under Add to cart and your email at the bottom of the page. Over the next weeks, keep an eye on how many visits turn into orders (your conversion rate) in your Shopify reports, and on the number of new reviews coming in through Judge.me.

  5. 5. Bestsellers first in every collection

    Free Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 1 hour 0/7

    “On your Gifts Under £10 page I counted 656 products over 41 pages. There's no visible sort order, no breadcrumb under the header and no stock status on the product cards, and the only filters are Availability and Price. You already put Sale badges on some items and you have a Best Sellers collection, but someone landing on Gifts Under £10 can't jump straight to the deals or see your winners first, so they just scroll through whatever comes up. Most people give up after a page or two, and in a shop full of pocket-money buys that's an order gone. Today you put your best sellers at the top of your collections, add an On sale filter next to Availability and Price, and switch on stock status and breadcrumbs wherever your theme lets you.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You + a developer for one part
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In your admin, click:Products › Collections

      Open the Gifts Under £10 collection. In the Collection items section, click the Default sort drop-down, choose Best selling and click Save. Your proven sellers now fill the first rows shoppers see.

      Editing collection details and layoutShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Products › Collections

      Do the same for the collections behind your menu, starting with Lisa's Picks, Pocket Money Toys < £5, Seasonal Collection and SALE!. Best selling counts all-time orders, so the order gets sharper as sales come in.

      Editing collection details and layoutShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Products › Search and filter › Tag

      In Products, click Search and filter, then Tag, and look for a tag like Sale. If your marked-down items don't have one, select them in the product list and add the tag Sale. The filter in the next step needs it.

      Creating and using tags in ShopifyShopify Help Center
    5. In your admin, click:Apps › Search & Discovery › Filters

      If Shopify Search & Discovery (free, made by Shopify) isn't in your Apps yet, install it. Click Add filter, choose Tags as the Source and rename it Deals. Group the Sale tag into one value called On sale, then save. It shows next to Availability and Price.

      Adding filters with Shopify Search & DiscoveryShopify Help Center
    6. In your admin, click:Online Store › Themes › Customize

      In the theme editor, open your collection page and click the product grid section. Turn on sorting if there's a setting for it. Then look under Theme settings, Product cards, for a stock or inventory option, and on the collection page for breadcrumbs. If you can't find them, forward the developer brief.

      Customizing theme settingsShopify Help Center
    7. Open lisaslobby.com/collections/gifts-under-10 on your phone. Your top sellers should come first and Deals should sit next to Availability and Price. Tapping On sale should leave only items with a Sale badge.

    Ready to paste: Filter name and value in Search & Discovery

    Filter name: Deals. Value: On sale

    Ready to paste: Stock line on each product card in the collection grid

    In stock / Low stock: [number] left / Sold out

    Ready to paste: Breadcrumb under the header on collection pages

    Home / Gifts Under £10

    How you’ll know it worked

    Open Gifts Under £10 in a private window. The first row should show your best sellers, and the Deals filter with On sale should sit next to Availability and Price. Over the next weeks, watch the add-to-cart rate from collection pages in your Analytics. Next time, set Best selling on the rest of your collections and tag every new markdown as Sale.

    For your developer

    Forward this to your developer. This part is for them:

    Please make three changes on the lisaslobby.com collection pages, for example /collections/gifts-under-10. 1) Add a breadcrumb under the header in the format Home / [collection name]. 2) Show a stock line on each product card in the grid, using the same wording as the product page: In stock, Low stock: [number] left, Sold out. 3) If the Deals filter (Tags source) in Shopify Search & Discovery lists unrelated tags, replace it with a true/false product metafield filter called On sale. Use built-in theme settings where they exist before editing code. It's done when Gifts Under £10 shows the breadcrumb and stock lines on mobile and desktop, and the Deals filter offers only On sale.

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Those were fixes 4 and 5, the easy ones. The 3 biggest problems cost you the most orders.

For each of them I’ll write you a guide: what’s wrong, where to click in Shopify, what to paste, how to check it worked.

All 3 for $5, on your private page in a few minutes. If they don’t help, you get your money back.

Deal?