The most common online store mistakes

Big Tony audited 417 online stores in 7 markets. These are the checks they fail most often, why each one costs sales and what to fix first.

Updated

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Common mistakes aren't always your biggest sales leaks

The average store fails 13 of about 51 checks, and this ranking shows which mistakes turn up most often. Your lesson: fix what gets between shoppers and buying before chasing every shiny extra.

The 10 most common mistakes

  1. No chatbot available

    Homepage Small impact on sales

    69%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 47% Czechia: 68% Slovakia: 64% Poland: 86% Hungary: 89%

    Why it costs you: A chatbot can help shoppers get quick answers, but it's a nice-to-have, not your biggest sales leak. Don't hire a robot before fixing the buying basics.

    What to do: List common shopper questions and consider a chatbot only if it can answer them reliably or hand off to real help.

    See it in a real audit:jdsdesign-nz.myshopify.com30

  2. No filter for discounted products

    Category page Big impact on sales

    67%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 100% Czechia: 51% Slovakia: 58% Poland: 77% Hungary: 74%

    Why it costs you: Bargain hunters want the deals, not a treasure hunt through your entire catalog. Without a sale filter, finding something within budget takes more work.

    What to do: Add a clearly labeled sale filter to product listings wherever discounted products are available.

    See it in a real audit:94degrees.store43

  3. No upgrade suggestions in the cart

    Checkout Medium impact on sales

    66%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 86% Czechia: 48% Slovakia: 53% Poland: 89% Hungary: 82%

    Why it costs you: A shopper may happily choose a better version if you explain the benefit. Without a relevant upgrade suggestion, that option can stay out of sight.

    What to do: Offer a relevant upgrade beside the cart item, with a clear benefit, price difference and easy way to switch.

    See it in a real audit:dealbyethan.gay60

  4. No specific delivery date promised

    Product page Medium impact on sales

    64%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 81% Czechia: 47% Slovakia: 66% Poland: 81% Hungary: 59%

    Why it costs you: Shoppers need to know whether an order will arrive in time. Making them guess can turn an otherwise suitable product into a risky purchase.

    What to do: Show a realistic arrival date or date range on the product page, accounting for stock, destination and dispatch time.

    See it in a real audit:ericsalodesign.com74

  5. No complementary products in the cart

    Checkout Medium impact on sales

    58%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 61% Czechia: 37% Slovakia: 63% Poland: 78% Hungary: 66%

    Why it costs you: Shoppers may not realize they need a compatible extra until the order arrives. A useful suggestion can complete the purchase, rather than just pad it.

    What to do: Suggest relevant, compatible extras in the cart, with clear prices and an easy add button that doesn't interrupt checkout.

    See it in a real audit:vintagebookden.co.uk28

  6. Product variants are hard to select

    Product page Big impact on sales

    56%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 46% Czechia: 50% Slovakia: 61% Poland: 54% Hungary: 70%

    Why it costs you: If choosing a size or color feels like cracking a safe, buying gets harder. Shoppers need to see what's available and what they've selected.

    What to do: Clearly label variant choices, distinguish unavailable options and make the selected option unmistakable.

    See it in a real audit:seductiveutopia.net51

  7. Product variants lack structured attributes

    Product page Medium impact on sales

    55%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 45% Czechia: 49% Slovakia: 60% Poland: 54% Hungary: 70%

    Why it costs you: When size, color or material is buried in product names or descriptions, shoppers have to decode the options. That can make comparison and selection harder.

    What to do: Give each variant separate, consistently named attributes such as size, color and material, then use those attributes in the selector.

    See it in a real audit:boingbikes.com44

  8. No third-party trust badge

    Homepage Medium impact on sales

    49%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 38% Czechia: 39% Slovakia: 56% Poland: 55% Hungary: 52%

    Why it costs you: An unfamiliar store is asking shoppers to take a chance. A genuine, verifiable third-party endorsement can offer reassurance beyond your own promise that you're trustworthy.

    What to do: If you hold a relevant independent certification or verified rating, display its badge visibly and link to the proof.

    See it in a real audit:subversivcollective.com26

  9. Main homepage content loads slowly on phones

    Homepage Big impact on sales

    46%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 70% Czechia: 39% Slovakia: 43% Poland: 45% Hungary: 39%

    Why it costs you: Mobile shoppers came to see your products, not admire a blank screen. Waiting for the main content can get in the way before shopping even starts.

    What to do: Test your homepage on mobile, identify what's delaying the main content and tackle the biggest bottleneck first.

    See it in a real audit:seductiveutopiaapac.com46

  10. Accepted payment methods aren't shown upfront

    Homepage Medium impact on sales

    43%
    of stores

    English-speaking world: 27% Czechia: 53% Slovakia: 51% Poland: 52% Hungary: 27%

    Why it costs you: Shoppers shouldn't have to reach checkout to discover whether they can pay. Showing accepted methods early removes a question that could stop them going further.

    What to do: Display the payment methods you actually accept in a clearly visible area of your homepage.

    See it in a real audit:dollyandco.uk51

Also often missed

  1. No product reviews or ratings

    Product page

    42%
  2. Product lists lack a shopper-focused default order

    Category page

    41%
  3. No visible checkout progress indicator

    Checkout

    41%
  4. No brief returns information on product pages

    Product page

    40%
  5. Free delivery eligibility isn't clear at checkout

    Checkout

    37%
  6. No store blog with articles

    Homepage

    36%
  7. No visible homepage deals or discounts

    Homepage

    36%
  8. No similar products on product pages

    Product page

    36%
  9. Homepage responds slowly to taps

    Homepage

    33%
  10. No social proof on product pages

    Product page

    33%

“Recognize a few of these? Get a Big Tony audit to find out which mistakes your store makes and what to tackle first.”

Where does your store stand?

Get your own score and the fix that brings the most money.

Audit my store

How Tony counts

Every store Tony has audited, in every market, one audit per store (the newest). A check counts as failed when the audit found the store doesn’t meet it; checks Tony couldn’t test are left out. Only checks tested in at least a third of the audits are ranked. The impact on sales is the weight a check has in Tony’s score. A market’s own share is shown once at least 10 of its stores were tested.

More insights

All insights