Online stores by category

Does what you sell decide how well your store sells? The average Big Tony audit score per product category, with what each kind of store misses most.

Updated

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Your products don't decide the result. Your store setup does.

Category averages sit fairly close together: what you sell isn't your destiny. Across the comparison, polished homepages often give way to weaker browsing or product pages. Before you redecorate the shop window, fix whatever makes buying harder.

Ranking by average score

  1. Kids, baby & toys

    24 audited stores

    77
    average score

    All stores: 72 29% scored 85+ Scores 29–100

    Strong checkout, fiddly product choices

    This modest sample averages above stores overall, with checkout strongest and product pages weakest. Awkward variant selection makes choosing a child's size or toy option harder than it needs to be. Fix those selectors first; parents have enough tiny buttons to deal with.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 81
    • Category page 75
    • Product page 74
    • Checkout 82

    Most often missed here

    • No chatbot available Missed by 75% of stores · all stores 69%
    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 61% of stores · all stores 56%
    • Variant attributes lack a structured format Missed by 61% of stores · all stores 55%
  2. Beauty & cosmetics

    24 audited stores

    76
    average score

    All stores: 72 33% scored 85+ Scores 34–97

    Good browsing, tangled shade choices

    In this modest sample, the average beats stores overall; homepages and category pages share the lead, while product pages trail. Variant selection fails more often than elsewhere, making shade or size choices unnecessarily awkward. Start by making each option clear and easy to select.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 81
    • Category page 81
    • Product page 71
    • Checkout 78

    Most often missed here

    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 77% of stores · all stores 56%
    • Variant attributes lack a structured format Missed by 77% of stores · all stores 55%
    • No specific delivery date promised Missed by 77% of stores · all stores 64%
  3. Fashion & shoes

    60 audited stores

    75
    average score

    All stores: 72 18% scored 85+ Scores 37–99

    Product pages shine; browsing needs tailoring

    Fashion averages above stores overall, with product pages strongest and category pages weakest. Missing discount filters make bargain hunters sift through the whole rack. Add a sale filter first so shoppers can find clothes within their budget without turning browsing into a part-time job.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 76
    • Category page 70
    • Product page 81
    • Checkout 79

    Most often missed here

    • No filter for discounted products Missed by 75% of stores · all stores 67%
    • No chatbot available Missed by 73% of stores · all stores 69%
    • No specific delivery date promised Missed by 63% of stores · all stores 64%
  4. Home & furniture

    52 audited stores

    74
    average score

    All stores: 72 19% scored 85+ Scores 47–96

    Welcoming entrance, weaker aisles

    Home stores average slightly above stores overall, with homepages strongest and category pages weakest. Cart recommendations for complementary products are often missing, leaving shoppers without helpful prompts for a coordinated purchase. Start with relevant cart suggestions, such as matching pieces, rather than throwing the warehouse at them.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 79
    • Category page 70
    • Product page 73
    • Checkout 76

    Most often missed here

    • No higher-value product suggestions in the cart Missed by 79% of stores · all stores 66%
    • No complementary product suggestions in the cart Missed by 72% of stores · all stores 58%
    • No chatbot available Missed by 69% of stores · all stores 69%
  5. DIY, tools & garden

    28 audited stores

    74
    average score

    All stores: 72 21% scored 85+ Scores 55–93

    Product choices need a better toolkit

    This modest sample averages slightly above stores overall; homepages and checkout tie for strongest, with product pages weakest. Awkward variant selection is more common here, making the right tool size or specification harder to choose. Fix the option selectors first: buying a drill shouldn't require detective work.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 78
    • Category page 74
    • Product page 67
    • Checkout 78

    Most often missed here

    • No chatbot available Missed by 71% of stores · all stores 69%
    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 71% of stores · all stores 56%
    • No higher-value product suggestions in the cart Missed by 71% of stores · all stores 66%
  6. Food & drinks

    22 audited stores

    74
    average score

    All stores: 72 18% scored 85+ Scores 48–92

    Checkout delivers; product choices need work

    In this modest sample, the average sits slightly above stores overall, with checkout strongest and product pages weakest. Variant selection is a frequent stumble, complicating choices such as flavour or pack size. Make those options clear and easy to select before polishing the checkout again.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 79
    • Category page 72
    • Product page 66
    • Checkout 82

    Most often missed here

    • No chatbot available Missed by 86% of stores · all stores 69%
    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 82% of stores · all stores 56%
    • Variant attributes lack a structured format Missed by 77% of stores · all stores 55%
  7. Sports & outdoor

    20 audited stores

    74
    average score

    All stores: 72 25% scored 85+ Scores 48–92

    Strong start, checkout loses momentum

    This modest sample averages slightly above stores overall; homepages lead and checkout trails. Missing progress indicators and unclear form feedback occur more often here, leaving shoppers unsure what's left or what went wrong. Start by making checkout progress and field errors obvious, especially for someone buying before a trip.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 79
    • Category page 78
    • Product page 73
    • Checkout 71

    Most often missed here

    • No higher-value product suggestions in the cart Missed by 81% of stores · all stores 66%
    • No chatbot available Missed by 75% of stores · all stores 69%
    • No specific delivery date promised Missed by 68% of stores · all stores 64%
  8. Jewellery & watches

    17 audited stores

    73
    average score

    All stores: 72 24% scored 85+ Scores 44–96

    Checkout sparkles; browsing needs polish

    In this modest sample, the average sits just above stores overall; checkout leads and category pages trail. Discount filters are often missing, making it harder to browse gifts within a budget. Add that filter first so shoppers can narrow the choice without opening every shiny thing.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 77
    • Category page 71
    • Product page 77
    • Checkout 78

    Most often missed here

    • No chatbot available Missed by 76% of stores · all stores 69%
    • No filter for discounted products Missed by 71% of stores · all stores 67%
    • No complementary product suggestions in the cart Missed by 64% of stores · all stores 58%
  9. Health & supplements

    38 audited stores

    72
    average score

    All stores: 72 26% scored 85+ Scores 34–96

    Checkout works; finding products needs attention

    Health stores match the overall average, with checkout strongest and category pages weakest. Stock visibility in listings is missing more often here, making it harder to spot an available supplement before opening its page. Show availability directly in product listings first; don't make shoppers investigate every bottle.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 78
    • Category page 60
    • Product page 74
    • Checkout 81

    Most often missed here

    • No filter for discounted products Missed by 75% of stores · all stores 67%
    • No chatbot available Missed by 74% of stores · all stores 69%
    • No specific delivery date promised Missed by 63% of stores · all stores 64%
  10. Pets

    15 audited stores

    71
    average score

    All stores: 72 27% scored 85+ Scores 22–99

    Smooth checkout, awkward product options

    This modest sample averages just below stores overall, with checkout strongest and category pages weakest. Variant selection is a frequent problem, making food pack sizes or collar sizes harder to choose. Fix those selectors first so shoppers can confidently pick what fits their pet.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 76
    • Category page 69
    • Product page 70
    • Checkout 80

    Most often missed here

    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 73% of stores · all stores 56%
    • Variant attributes lack a structured format Missed by 73% of stores · all stores 55%
    • No filter for discounted products Missed by 71% of stores · all stores 67%
  11. Car & moto

    16 audited stores

    69
    average score

    All stores: 72 13% scored 85+ Scores 44–90

    Good entrance; browsing needs a tune-up

    In this modest sample, the average falls below stores overall; homepages lead and category pages trail. Discount filters are commonly missing, making it harder to narrow accessories or supplies by budget. Add a sale filter first, while keeping product specifications clear enough to judge suitability.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 77
    • Category page 67
    • Product page 69
    • Checkout 72

    Most often missed here

    • No filter for discounted products Missed by 87% of stores · all stores 67%
    • No higher-value product suggestions in the cart Missed by 82% of stores · all stores 66%
    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 73% of stores · all stores 56%
  12. Electronics & appliances

    19 audited stores

    68
    average score

    All stores: 72 21% scored 85+ Scores 40–91

    Checkout ready, product choices tangled

    This modest sample averages below stores overall, with checkout strongest and product pages weakest. Variant selection fails more often here, complicating choices between capacities, colours or configurations. Fix those selectors first so shoppers can tell exactly which version they're putting in the cart.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 75
    • Category page 68
    • Product page 59
    • Checkout 78

    Most often missed here

    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 89% of stores · all stores 56%
    • Variant attributes lack a structured format Missed by 89% of stores · all stores 55%
    • No specific delivery date promised Missed by 78% of stores · all stores 64%
  13. Hobby, gifts & books

    52 audited stores

    67
    average score

    All stores: 72 12% scored 85+ Scores 28–94

    Inviting homepage, harder treasure hunt

    These stores average below stores overall, with homepages strongest and category pages weakest. Attribute filters are missing more often here, making it harder to narrow gifts, books or hobby supplies to something suitable. Start with filters that match how your shoppers choose; treasure hunts belong in the products.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 76
    • Category page 64
    • Product page 68
    • Checkout 73

    Most often missed here

    • No filter for discounted products Missed by 79% of stores · all stores 67%
    • No higher-value product suggestions in the cart Missed by 77% of stores · all stores 66%
    • Product variants are awkward to select Missed by 61% of stores · all stores 56%

“Your category's average isn't your store's verdict. Get a Big Tony audit and find out where you stand—and what deserves fixing first.”

Where does your store stand?

Get your own score and the fix that brings the most money.

Audit my store

How Tony counts

Each store gets one category: what most of its products are. All markets together, one audit per store (the newest), categories with at least 5 audited stores. Stores selling services, digital goods or a bit of everything are left out of the ranking. The score shows how well the audited stores are set up to sell, not how profitable a category is.

More insights

All insights