E‑commerce platforms compared

How well do stores on each platform sell? The average Big Tony audit score of real stores, with Tony’s take on every platform.

Updated

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Shopify stores hit average. Category pages need work.

The audited Shopify stores match the overall average, but their category pages lag behind their homepages. These results reflect store setup, not platform quality—you can fix most of what I check without packing up and moving platforms.

Ranking by average score

  1. Shopify

    58 audited stores

    65
    average score

    All stores: 65 3% scored 85+ Scores 28–87

    Homepages lead; category pages need attention.

    Shopify stores average 65, matching the overall average; homepages lead at 75, while category pages trail at 61. Check your category filters first: discounted-product filtering was missing in 100% of audited Shopify stores, matching the finding across all audited stores.

    Average score by page

    • Homepage 75
    • Category page 61
    • Product page 69
    • Checkout 73

    Most common failed checks

    • Is there a filter for discounted products available? Failed in 100% of stores
    • Is a checkout progress indicator visible? Failed in 98% of stores
    • Is there up-sell in the cart? Failed in 89% of stores

    Audits of stores on Shopify

    Show more audits

“Your platform badge can't tell you where your store needs work. Get a Big Tony audit and find out what to tackle first.”

Where does your store stand?

Get your own score and the fix that brings the most money.

Audit my store

How Tony counts

Only audits Tony wrote in English, one per store (the newest), and only platforms with at least 3 audited stores. The score shows how well a store is set up to sell: homepage, categories, product pages, cart and checkout. On any platform most of that is up to the owner, so it is not a verdict on the platform itself.

More insights

All insights