Conversion audit for vintagebookden.co.uk

Shopify 54 checks · 4 pages

Money’s leaking
57 points short of a great score (85+)

Your shelves should earn more than this

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

At 28/100, The Vintage Book Den needs more than a little polishing to earn its keep. The homepage and the Gazetteer page should work harder to turn interest into money. The three biggest changes below tackle the expensive gaps first; rearranging the furniture can wait.

Tony found 26 problems

Tony went through vintagebookden.co.uk like a customer would and ran 54 checks on 4 pages.

Visitors

How many people come to the store, by Google's data

1 problem here is part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

First impression

Across the whole store: trust, contacts, speed

  • Does the main content appear within 2.5 seconds on a phone? Serious

    Google's test on a typical phone (product page): the main content appears after 3.2 s (goal: under 2.5 s). For your developer: Render-blocking requests.

  • Are there links to social media pages? (Warning)

    No social media links are shown on this page.

  • Is a newsletter signup form available? (Warning)

    No newsletter signup form is shown on this page.

  • Is there a third-party trust badge? (Warning)

    No independent trust or review badge is shown on the page.

3 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Homepage

The Vintage Book Den

vintagebookden.co.uk/
  • Are any discounts or deals visible on the homepage? (Warning)

    No discounts, deals, or promotional offers are shown.

1 problem here is part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Category page

Vintage Fiction & Classic Books – The Vintage Book Den

vintagebookden.co.uk/collections/fiction-classics
  • Is product stock availability visible in the category product listing? Serious

    The listing shows no stock status on individual product cards.

  • Is the category product list sorted by default by popularity, recommendation, or best sellers? Serious

    The preselected order is alphabetical, not popularity or recommendations.

  • Is there a filter for discounted products available? Serious

    The available filter groups do not include a discount filter.

  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under the header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb navigation is shown beneath the header.

Product page

1830 The New Lancashire Gazetteer, Stephen R. Clarke – The Vintage Book Den

vintagebookden.co.uk/products/1830-the-new-lancashire-gazetteer-topographical-dictionary-stephen-r-clarke
  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under the header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb trail is shown beneath the header.

  • Is there any social proof? (Warning)

    No customer reviews, ratings, testimonials, or other social proof are shown.

  • Are product reviews and ratings present? (Warning)

    No product review or rating is shown.

3 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Cart

  • Is there a clear way back to shopping? Serious

    No continue shopping link was visible in the cart.

  • Does the cart or checkout show free delivery, or how much more to spend to get it? Serious

    No free delivery message was shown.

  • Is there cross-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No related products were shown in the cart.

  • Is there up-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No upgrade or add-on offer was shown.

Checkout

  • Does the form avoid unnecessary required fields? Serious

    Phone became required after address entry.

  • Is a checkout progress indicator visible? (Warning)

    No step tracker was visible.

How to fix it

Tony priced the fixes for your store. The last two are on the house.

Tony’s quote

No. 201C1037
November 22, 2026

for vintagebookden.co.uk

#FixPrice
  1. 1 The biggest problem included
  2. 2 The second biggest problem included
  3. 3 The third biggest problem included
  4. 4 Give Fiction & Classics a selling order On the house
  5. 5 Stop demanding unnecessary phone numbers On the house

Step-by-step guides, click by click in Shopify

Total for fixes 1–3 $5

about $2 a fix

One-time payment · Ready in minutes · Money back if it doesn’t help

Tony
  1. The biggest problem

    Fix #1 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Visitors

    Show the problem and the fix
  2. The second biggest problem

    Fix #2 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Product page

    Show the problem and the fix
  3. The third biggest problem

    Fix #3 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact First impressionHomepage

    Show the problem and the fix
  4. 4. Give Fiction & Classics selling order

    On the house Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 25 minutes 0/4

    “On vintagebookden.co.uk, your Store menu already says Fiction & Classics, but that collection opens with the heading Available Books. Its 32 items default to Alphabetically, A-Z, so the opening selection follows titles rather than your bookseller’s judgement. A shopper has to dig instead of meeting the copies you would put straight into their hands. That risks losing an order before the right book gets noticed. Today, you’ll match the heading to the menu and hand-pick the opening selection—let the bookseller run the shelf, not the alphabet.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You can do it yourself
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In your admin, click:Products › Collections

      Open Products, then Collections, and find the collection behind your Fiction & Classics menu link, currently headed Available Books. Change its existing title to Fiction & Classics and click Save; leave its description alone.

      Edit collection detailsShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Products › Collections

      Stay in that collection and find Collection items. Open Default sort, select Manually, and click Save; this sets the collection’s opening product order on your store.

      Sort collection productsShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Products › Collections

      Review the 32 books and confirm which copies are available, then choose six you would recommend first. Consider 1866 Arabian Nights Entertainments, Routledge and 1902 Pickwick Papers Volume 2, Charles Dickens without assuming they deserve top billing. Drag your chosen six into the opening positions and click Save.

      Arrange collection productsShopify Help Center

    Ready to paste: Existing fiction collection title

    Fiction & Classics

    How you’ll know it worked

    In a fresh private browser window, use Store > Fiction & Classics and confirm the heading and first six books match your choices without touching the sort control. Over the next few weeks, watch orders containing those opening books; next time, refresh this selection as copies sell.

  5. 5. Stop demanding unnecessary phone numbers

    On the house Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 20 minutes 0/4

    “In the checkout test on vintagebookden.co.uk, your phone field became required after address entry for 1830 The New Lancashire Gazetteer, Stephen R. Clarke. Your shopper could reach checkout without creating an account, but then had to hand over a phone number. If it isn't needed, that's another reason to walk away with the book still unpaid for. Today you'll check who genuinely needs that number and, if nobody does, stop making it the price of admission.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You can do it yourself
    1. Open the admin login
    2. Check your shipping service's booking requirements and your payment providers' requirements for a customer phone number. If either genuinely requires it, keep the requirement and stop here; otherwise, continue with Optional.

      Checkout form optionsShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Settings › Checkout

      Open Settings, then Checkout, and find Customer information. Set Shipping address phone number to Optional if it isn't already, then click Save; leave Customer contact method unchanged. The phone field stays in the checkout shipping address form without demanding an answer.

      Checkout form optionsShopify Help Center
    4. Wait 30 seconds, then open a fresh private browsing window and add 1830 The New Lancashire Gazetteer, Stephen R. Clarke. Enter your email and a valid delivery address, leave phone blank, and check that no required-phone error appears; stop before placing an order.

      Checkout form optionsShopify Help Center

    How you’ll know it worked

    After address entry, confirm the phone field remains optional and leaving it blank produces no required-phone warning. Over the next few weeks, watch the percentage of shoppers reaching checkout who complete a purchase.

Tony’s quote for fixes 1–3 still stands.