Conversion audit for craftycutslaser.com

Shopify 58 checks · 4 pages

Money’s leaking
45 points short of a great score (85+)

Too many pages are leaving money on the table

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Crafty Cuts Laser is leaving too much money between the homepage and the order. The product and collection pages need serious work, not another coat of digital paint. Tackle the three biggest changes first, then handle the smaller fixes without turning this into a six-month renovation.

Tony found 23 problems

Tony went through craftycutslaser.com like a customer would and ran 58 checks on 4 pages.

Visitors

How many people come to the store, by Google's data

1 problem here is part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

First impression

Across the whole store: trust, contacts, speed

  • Is a phone number or email visible in the header or footer? Serious

    No phone number or email is shown in the header or footer.

  • Does the main content appear within 2.5 seconds on a phone? Serious

    Google's test on a typical phone (product page): the main content appears after 9.4 s (goal: under 2.5 s). For your developer: Use efficient cache lifetimes.

  • Is there a third-party trust badge? (Warning)

    No independent trust badge or review widget is detected on the page.

  • Is the store's text free of grammar and spelling errors? (Warning)

    Menu labels contain a misplaced apostrophe and a missing apostrophe.

    • Dangly Doodad's Dangly Doodads
    • 🤰Mothers Day 🤰Mother's Day

Category page

Mother's Day | Crafty Cuts Laser

craftycutslaser.com/collections/mothers-day
  • Is there a filter for discounted products available? Serious

    No discount filter is visible among the collection controls.

  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under the header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb navigation is visible between the header and collection content.

3 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Product page

Mini Bamboo Koala Bear Face - 10 Pairs | Crafty Cuts Laser

craftycutslaser.com/products/koala-bear-face-laser-cut-earrings-supplies
  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under the header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb navigation is shown between the header and product content.

  • Is there any social proof? (Warning)

    No product reviews, ratings, testimonials, or customer-generated proof are shown.

  • Are product reviews and ratings present? (Warning)

    No customer review count or product rating is shown.

  • Are product parameters displayed in a structured format? (Warning)

    Sizing details appear in descriptive text rather than a table, definition list, or bullet list.

5 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Checkout

Cart and checkout, with a real product in the cart

craftycutslaser.com/cart

Cart

  • Does the cart or checkout show free delivery, or how much more to spend to get it? Serious

    No free delivery message or threshold was shown.

  • Is there cross-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No related product offers were visible in cart.

  • Is there up-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No upgrade or add-on offer was visible.

Checkout

  • Is a checkout progress indicator visible? (Warning)

    No step tracker was visible on checkout.

How to fix it

Tony priced the fixes for your store. The last two are on the house.

Tony’s quote

No. 59E3D009
November 22, 2026

for craftycutslaser.com

#FixPrice
  1. 1 The biggest problem included
  2. 2 The second biggest problem included
  3. 3 The third biggest problem included
  4. 4 Put a real email in the footer On the house
  5. 5 Give the cart a bigger-order nudge On the house

Step-by-step guides, click by click in Shopify

Total for fixes 1–3 $5

about $2 a fix

One-time payment · Ready in minutes · Money back if it doesn’t help

Tony
  1. The biggest problem

    Fix #1 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Visitors

    Show the problem and the fix
  2. The second biggest problem

    Fix #2 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Product page

    Show the problem and the fix
  3. The third biggest problem

    Fix #3 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Category page

    Show the problem and the fix
  4. 4. Put your email in the footer

    On the house Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 15 minutes 0/5

    “On your craftycutslaser.com homepage, the footer already has a Contact link, and you also have Shopify Inbox chat. But there’s no email address or phone number visible in the header or footer. A first-time shopper wanting to email you has to go hunting, and that extra effort can turn a buying question into a quiet exit. Today, you’ll put a real, tappable email address beside Contact—no new app, no construction crew.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You can do it yourself
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In your admin, click:Content › Menus

      Pick a customer-service email inbox you actually check, and replace the placeholder below with it. Go to Content > Menus and open the menu whose links match your storefront footer, including Contact.

      Edit menusShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Content › Menus

      Click Add menu item and put your full email address in Name—not just “Email us.” In the link field, enter mailto: followed immediately by that same address, with no spaces, then click Add; the address itself will become the footer link.

      Add email linksShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Content › Menus

      Drag the email item’s handle so it sits immediately after Contact, at the same level rather than nested underneath it. Keep your existing Contact link and click Save or Save menu; the footer follows the menu’s order.

      Reorder menu itemsShopify Help Center
    5. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme

      Under Online Store, click Edit theme beside your live theme and use the mobile preview button to inspect the footer. Then open your live homepage on your phone and tap the address: confirm it opens an email draft addressed to your chosen inbox.

      Preview your themeShopify Help Center

    Ready to paste: Footer menu item: Name

    [your customer-service email address]

    How you’ll know it worked

    You’re done when the full address is readable beside Contact in the footer and tapping it on your phone opens a correctly addressed email draft. Over the next few weeks, count genuine pre-purchase email enquiries to see whether shoppers use it.

  5. 5. Give your cart a nudge

    On the house Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 75 minutes 0/7

    “Your homepage already advertises automatic spend-and-save discounts, so you have the carrot. But on craftycutslaser.com's cart page, I saw quantity controls, order notes and Continue shopping, with no related-product or add-on offers visible. A shopper has to leave the cart and hunt for useful Findings instead of seeing a sensible extra right there. That extra work can leave you with a smaller order. Today, you'll bring your existing rewards into the cart and give shoppers a small, useful selection of Findings—not another obstacle course.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You + a developer for one part
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In your admin, click:Discounts

      Open your existing discounts and confirm the advertised 8% at $80, 12% at $150, and $250 reward terms. Check currency and exclusions before writing the cart message; don't create duplicate discounts or change the offers.

      Manage discountsShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Products › Collections

      Check whether you already have a suitable collection; otherwise, create one called Findings for your next make. Manually add two or three in-stock Findings after checking their compatibility with your best-selling blanks, and make the collection available to Online Store.

      Create collectionsShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme

      Open Edit theme, then choose the cart template from the template selector. Look for existing cart recommendation settings first, then available text and collection sections; reuse suitable controls rather than duplicating them. If those options aren't available, give your developer the brief below.

      Sections and blocksShopify Help Center
    5. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme

      If available, use a text block or Rich text section on the cart template and paste the reward message below. Position it near the subtotal and checkout button where the editor allows; otherwise, have your developer place it there. Save your changes.

      Sections and blocksShopify Help Center
    6. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme

      Use an existing cart recommendation control if it lets you select those Findings; otherwise, add a Featured collection section if available and select your prepared collection. Use the heading below and place it beneath the cart items; have your developer handle missing controls and sold-out suppression.

      Sections and blocksShopify Help Center
    7. Using an available blank, check the cart on your phone and desktop, then try a compatible Finding. Test eligible baskets around $80 and $150 through checkout without paying; confirm the existing discounts apply and the $250 wording says upgrade, not free delivery.

      Automatic discountsShopify Help Center

    Ready to paste: Cart reward message near the subtotal

    Spend & Save: 8% off with a minimum spend of $80, or 12% off with a minimum spend of $150. Discounts applied automatically at checkout. Spend $250 for 15% off and a free Express Post Upgrade—not free delivery.

    Ready to paste: Findings collection name and cart section heading

    Findings for your next make

    How you’ll know it worked

    You're done when the cart shows the reward message and selected Findings, a compatible extra can be added, and eligible discounts appear at checkout; watch average order value over the next few weeks. Next time, refresh the Findings selection for your best sellers and remove anything no longer suitable.

    For your developer

    Forward this to your developer. This part is for them:

    Only handle gaps the current theme cannot cover without code. Add an editable reward message near the cart subtotal and a compact Findings section beneath the cart items, using the owner's selected collection and supplied copy. Show only in-stock selections, make product names, prices and purchase options clear, and do not imply every Finding fits every blank. Preserve existing discount logic, quantity controls, order notes and checkout. Verify on mobile and desktop that adding a Finding updates the cart correctly and that the $250 offer reads free Express Post Upgrade, never free delivery.

Tony’s quote for fixes 1–3 still stands.