Conversion audit for art-by-jay.co.uk

Shopify 58 checks · 4 pages

Money left on the table
18 points short of a great score (85+)

Too many art lovers leave with empty hands

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Art by Jay scores 67/100, leaving money between the browsing and the buying. The biggest gaps sit on your shopping pages and at the final stretch of ordering. Your three priority changes can turn more existing interest into paid orders—before you spend energy bringing more people through the door.

I picked the 5 fixes that matter most. The 3 biggest are in my guide. Fixes 4 and 5 I’ll show you right here, for free.

Tony found 15 problems

Tony went through art-by-jay.co.uk like a customer would and ran 58 checks on 4 pages.

Visitors

How many people come to the store, by Google's data

  • Does the store get enough visitors? (Warning)

    A steady flow of visitors. Google's Chrome data (October 2026) puts art-by-jay.co.uk among the 500,000 most visited sites in the UK. The busiest stores are among the top 100,000.

First impression

Across the whole store: trust, contacts, speed

  • Does the main content appear within 2.5 seconds on a phone? Serious

    Google's test on a typical phone (product page): the main content appears after 4.4 s (goal: under 2.5 s). For your developer: Render-blocking requests.

  • Is there own blog with articles? (Warning)

    No link to blog or articles found in menus or footer.

  • Are accepted payment methods shown? (Warning)

    No visible payment logos found on header/footer or page.

Homepage

Art by Jay | Cosy Countryside Wildlife Art & Gifts

art-by-jay.co.uk/
  • Are there any visible discounts / deals on homepage? (Warning)

    No discounts or deals are displayed on homepage.

Category page

Original Wildlife & Animal Artwork | Jay Foster – Art by Jay

art-by-jay.co.uk/collections/originals
  • Is there a filter for discounted products available? Serious

    No filter for discounted products visible in filters

Product page

Robin Mug | British Bird Gift | Art by Jay

art-by-jay.co.uk/products/robin-mug-11oz-ceramic-wildlife-coffee-cup
  • Are similar products present? (Warning)

    No similar products section identified on this page.

2 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Checkout

Cart and checkout, with a real product in the cart

art-by-jay.co.uk/cart

Cart

  • Is there cross-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No related product offers were visible in the cart.

  • Is there up-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No upgrade or extra service offer was visible.

Checkout

  • Is a checkout progress indicator visible? (Warning)

    No step tracker or progress bar was visible.

3 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

How to fix it

The 3 biggest problems are in Tony’s guide. Fixes 4 and 5 are open below, for free.

  1. The biggest problem

    Fix #1 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Product page

    Show the problem and the fix
  2. The second biggest problem

    Fix #2 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Checkout

    Show the problem and the fix
  3. The third biggest problem

    Fix #3 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Solid impact

    Show the problem and the fix
  4. 4. Offer another mug before they leave

    Free Small impact⚡ Quick win about 25 minutes 0/6

    “On your Robin Mug product page at art-by-jay.co.uk, I couldn't identify a similar-products section. If someone wants a mug but not a robin, you've left them to hunt for another design themselves. That's extra work at the very moment they might walk away without ordering. Today, you'll add a short 'Prefer another animal?' section linking to two available mugs. Keep it separate from 'Complete the Set': we're helping them choose a different mug, not asking them to buy matching extras.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You can do it yourself
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In your admin, click:Products

      Open Products and choose two mugs featuring different animals from the robin. Open each product and confirm Status is Active and Publishing includes Online Store; skip drafts, archived products and anything you aren't ready to sell.

      Product availabilityShopify Help Center
    3. In your admin, click:Products

      For each alternative, copy its exact product title, then click Preview. Confirm the mug is available to buy on the storefront and copy its product-page address, not an admin or preview address; replace sold-out choices.

      Preview a productShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Products

      Return to Products and open Robin Mug. In Description, paste the supplied text at the end of the main description, outside any 'Complete the Set' content; replace both bracketed names with the exact titles you collected.

      Product descriptionsShopify Help Center
    5. Highlight the first alternative's name and click Insert link. Enter its storefront address in Link to, use its product name as Link title, choose the same window under Open this link in, then click Insert link; repeat for the second mug.

      Insert linksShopify Help Center
    6. In your admin, click:Products

      Click Save, then Preview on Robin Mug. Check the new section appears in the product description, separately from 'Complete the Set'; on desktop and your phone, follow both links and confirm each opens the intended available mug.

      Save and preview productsShopify Help Center

    Ready to paste: End of the Robin Mug description

    Prefer another animal? Take a look at these alternative mug designs: [First alternative mug's exact product name] [Second alternative mug's exact product name]

    How you’ll know it worked

    You're done when both names open the correct available mugs and the section stays separate from 'Complete the Set' on mobile and desktop. Over the next few weeks, watch your online store conversion rate for signs of improvement, not proof that these links alone caused it.

  5. 5. Show payment choices before product pages

    Free Small impact⚡ Quick win 0/3

    “Don’t make people reach the till before discovering you take their wallet. Showing accepted payment choices earlier removes a small uncertainty before visitors invest time choosing artwork or gifts.”

    Do this

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Those were fixes 4 and 5, the easy ones. The 3 biggest problems cost you the most orders.

For each of them I’ll write you a guide: what’s wrong, where to click in Shopify, what to paste, how to check it worked.

All 3 for $5, on your private page in a few minutes. If they don’t help, you get your money back.

Deal?