Conversion audit for topshelfdealz.com

Shopify 49 checks · 3 pages

Money’s leaking
57 points short of a great score (85+)

Your product pages and cart leave real gift money behind

Big Tony
your e-commerce uncle

Top Shelf Dealz scores 28 out of 100, and that is tough-love territory. The biggest leaks sit on the product pages, where gift shoppers decide, and in the cart, where every order could be bigger. This is not a couple of small tweaks away from selling steadily; the gap is wide. The three biggest fixes below are what close it.

Tony found 23 problems

Tony went through topshelfdealz.com like a customer would and ran 49 checks on 3 pages.

Visitors

How many people come to the store, by Google's data

1 problem here is part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

First impression

Across the whole store: trust, contacts, speed

  • Is there own blog with articles? - Check whether a link to blog is present (Warning)

    No blog link is visible in the page content or footer.

  • Is there chatbot available? (Warning)

    No chat button, chat link, or chatbot widget is visible.

4 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Homepage

Top Shelf Dealz

topshelfdealz.com/
  • Is there shopping cart preview with mini cart preview? Serious

    A cart link is present, but no item count appears beside it.

  • Are there any visible discounts / deals on homepage? (Warning)

    No discounted prices, sale labels, or specific deals are visible.

1 problem here is part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Product page

Christmas Bengal Cat Mom Wall Art & Signs – Top Shelf Dealz

topshelfdealz.com/products/christmas-bengal-cat-mom-wall-art-signs
  • Is product variant selection usable? Serious

    No selectable product options such as size or color are shown.

  • Is there breadcrumb navigation under the header? (Warning)

    No breadcrumb navigation is shown beneath the header.

  • Are variant attributes defined structurally? (Warning)

    No selectable variant attributes are provided.

6 problems here are part of the 3 biggest fixes in Tony’s guide.

See the guide

Checkout

Cart and checkout, with a real product in the cart

topshelfdealz.com/cart

Cart

  • Does the cart or checkout show free delivery, or how much more to spend to get it? Serious

    No free delivery message was shown.

  • Is there cross-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No related products were shown in cart.

  • Is there up-sell in the cart? (Warning)

    No upgrade or extra service offer appeared.

Checkout

  • Is a checkout progress indicator visible? (Warning)

    No step tracker was visible.

How to fix it

Tony priced the fixes for your store. The last two are on the house.

Tony’s quote

No. 76A8C94F
November 22, 2026

for topshelfdealz.com

#FixPrice
  1. 1 The biggest problem included
  2. 2 The second biggest problem included
  3. 3 The third biggest problem included
  4. 4 Offer add-ons right in the cart On the house
  5. 5 Put a gift deal on the homepage On the house

Step-by-step guides, click by click in Shopify

Total for fixes 1–3 $5

about $2 a fix

One-time payment · Ready in minutes · Money back if it doesn’t help

Tony
  1. The biggest problem

    Fix #1 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact Visitors

    Show the problem and the fix
  2. The second biggest problem

    Fix #2 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact First impressionProduct page

    Show the problem and the fix
  3. The third biggest problem

    Fix #3 is hidden: it’s in Tony’s guide

    Serious problem Big impact First impressionHomepageProduct page

    Show the problem and the fix
  4. 4. Add-on picks in your cart

    On the house Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 60 minutes 0/7

    “I went through your cart at topshelfdealz.com/cart and nothing extra gets offered there: no matching piece, no gift packaging, no upgrade. On the homepage, the cart link sits up top with no number next to it, so a shopper can't see at a glance what they've already picked. Someone buying a necklace as a gift would often grab the matching bracelet or a gift box too, but nobody asks them, so they pay for one thing and leave. That's extra money from a buyer who was already at the register. Today you pair your necklaces with add-ons, make the cart slide open when someone adds a piece, and get those suggestions in front of shoppers before they pay.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You + a developer for one part
    1. Open the admin login
    2. In the Shopify App Store, install Shopify Search & Discovery. It's free, it's made by Shopify, and it lets you pick which products get suggested with each item.

      Shopify Search & Discovery appShopify Help Center
    3. If you don't sell gift packaging yet, add it in Products like any other item: title Gift box, price [gift box price], a clear photo and the description below. Set it to Active and keep it in stock, or the app hides it.

      Customize product recommendationsShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Apps › Search & Discovery

      Click Product recommendations, then Add recommendations. Pick a best-selling necklace and under Complementary products add its matching bracelet and the gift box. Do the same for your top [number] necklaces first.

      Customize product recommendationsShopify Help Center
    5. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme › Products › Default product

      If you see a Complementary products block in the product information section, click it. If not, click Add block and choose Complementary products. Set Maximum products to show to 2 or 3, then Save.

      Customize product recommendationsShopify Help Center
    6. In your admin, click:Online Store › Edit theme › Theme settings › Cart

      Set Cart type to Drawer so the cart slides open with the items when someone adds a piece, and they stay on the page. Under Cart drawer, pick [your gift collection] to show when the cart is empty, then Save.

      Customizing theme settingsShopify Help Center
    7. The theme shows these pairings on product pages, not inside the cart. Forward the developer brief below so the same bracelet and gift box picks show in the cart drawer and on the cart page, and the cart icon shows a live item count.

    Ready to paste: Description of the new Gift box product

    Make it gift-ready. Your piece arrives in our [gift box description], ready to hand over, no wrapping needed. Add it to any order for [gift box price].

    Ready to paste: Heading above the add-ons in the cart (give to your developer)

    Complete the gift

    Ready to paste: Line under that heading in the cart (give to your developer)

    Add the matching bracelet or gift packaging for [gift box price], so it's ready to give the moment it arrives.

    How you’ll know it worked

    Add a necklace to the cart: the drawer should slide open, the necklace page should show its bracelet and gift box, and once your developer is done the cart shows them too with a number on the cart icon. Over the next weeks watch average order value in Analytics, and next time pair the rest of your products, not just the necklaces.

    For your developer

    Forward this to your developer. This part is for them:

    Cart add-ons for topshelfdealz.com (Shopify). 1) In the cart drawer and on the /cart page, add a small block headed Complete the gift with the line the owner gives you. Fill it with the complementary products set in the Shopify Search & Discovery app for the items in the cart (Product Recommendations API with intent=complementary). Show at most 3, skip anything already in the cart, and give each one an add-to-cart button. 2) Make sure the cart icon in the header shows the item count and updates as soon as something is added. Done when: you add a necklace, the drawer opens with the right count, its paired bracelet and gift box show up, and one click adds an add-on and updates the total on desktop and mobile.

  5. 5. Launch a homepage gift deal

    On the house Solid impact⚡ Quick win about 45 minutes 0/7

    “I looked at your topshelfdealz.com homepage and didn't see a single deal. No sale prices, no sale labels, no offer of any kind. Then I went to the cart, and nothing in there said anything about free delivery or how much more you'd need to spend to get it. So a shopper who's on the fence sees full prices, has no reason to buy today, and gets no nudge to add a bracelet to that necklace. Today you'll set up a necklace-plus-bracelet gift deal and a free shipping goal, then put both where people can't miss them: the top bar and the homepage.”

    Step by step in Shopify

    You can do it yourself
    1. Open the admin login
    2. Choose which necklaces and bracelets go in the deal. Whole collections are easiest. Pick a bracelet discount you can afford, like [15]%, and a free shipping amount a bit above your usual single-item price, like [amount]. Write both down, because you'll type them in a few places.

    3. In your admin, click:Discounts

      Click Create discount, pick Buy X get Y and select Automatic discount. Under Customer buys, set at least 1 item from your necklaces. Under Customer gets, set 1 bracelet at a Percentage of [15]. In Combinations, tick shipping discounts so it works with free shipping, then click Save.

      Buy X get Y discountsShopify Help Center
    4. In your admin, click:Discounts

      Click Create discount, pick Free shipping and select Automatic discount. Shoppers see the title in the cart and at checkout, so use the title below. Choose the countries, set Minimum purchase amount to [amount], pick All customers and click Save.

      Free shipping discountsShopify Help Center
    5. In your admin, click:Online Store

      Click Edit theme and open the Announcement bar section. Some themes call it Announcement banner or tuck it under Header. Click Add Announcement, paste the bar text below, link it to your necklaces and click Save. It shows at the very top of every page.

      Add an announcement barShopify Help Center
    6. Stay in the theme editor on the homepage. Use Add section right below the section with your Shop Now button and pick an image banner or text section that your theme offers. Paste the heading, text and button label below, link the button to your necklaces and click Save.

    7. On your phone, open topshelfdealz.com in a private window, add one necklace and one bracelet, then open the cart. You should see the bracelet discount. Go on to checkout and check that free shipping kicks in once the order passes [amount].

    Ready to paste: Announcement bar text

    Free shipping on orders over [amount] | Necklace + bracelet gift set: [15]% off the bracelet

    Ready to paste: Homepage deal banner, just below the Shop Now section (heading, text, button)

    The gift set deal Pick any necklace, add a bracelet, and the bracelet is [15]% off. The discount applies automatically in your cart, and orders over [amount] ship free. Button: Build your gift set

    Ready to paste: Discount titles in the admin, shown in cart and checkout

    Buy X get Y title: Gift set: [15]% off your bracelet Free shipping title: Free shipping over [amount]

    How you’ll know it worked

    You'll know it worked when the top bar and the deal banner show up on your homepage, and a necklace plus a bracelet in the cart shows the discount, with free shipping at checkout. Over the next few weeks, watch your average order value and how many orders have two or more items. Next time, try the free Shopify Bundles app to turn the set into its own product page.

Tony’s quote for fixes 1–3 still stands.