4. Match your payment promises
“Your homepage footer on mellskitchen.co.uk advertises Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and Klarna. But in the checkout test for 3 Day Meal Plan Subscription (6 meals), only credit card was selectable. A shopper expecting PayPal reaches the payment section and has to reconsider how to pay. That's an avoidable reason to leave dinner in the basket, even though your card option is already there. Today you'll check PayPal's setup and subscription approval, then make the footer match what you can actually accept.”
Step by step in Shopify
You can do it yourself- In your admin, click:Settings › Payments
Open Settings, then Payments, using your store-owner login. Note which advertised methods are active or need attention, especially PayPal under Additional payment methods; don't deactivate your existing card provider.
Open the guideShopify Help Center · help.shopify.com - In your admin, click:Settings › Payments
If PayPal shows Setup incomplete, click it, then Complete setup. Sign into your intended PayPal business account, complete the requested business details and permissions, then select Go back to Shopify; if setup is already complete, leave the connection alone.
Open the guideShopify Help Center · help.shopify.com - In your admin, click:Settings › Payments
On the Payments page, check PayPal's Reference Transactions approval status. Shopify requests this automatically for supported automatic billing, but hides PayPal on subscription orders without approval; if approval is pending or denied, contact PayPal support rather than repeatedly reconnecting the account.
Open the guideShopify Help Center · help.shopify.com Check whether 3 Day Meal Plan Subscription (6 meals) is currently available; if so, take it to checkout and look for selectable PayPal as well as credit card. Repeat with an available one-time meal plan to distinguish subscription restrictions, stopping before placing either order.
Open the guideShopify Help Center · help.shopify.comIn your theme editor, open Footer and compare its logos with your verified payment setup. Keep eligible wallets; absence in one browser alone isn't proof they're unsupported, but if confirmed unsupported logos remain, temporarily turn off Show payment icons and save rather than advertise unavailable methods.
Open the guideShopify Help Center · help.shopify.com
How you’ll know it worked
Refresh your homepage and checkout: the footer should make no unsupported payment promises, and an eligible checkout should offer PayPal alongside cards; watch the percentage of checkouts that become completed orders over the next few weeks. Next time, follow up any pending approval and complete a controlled PayPal transaction before restoring its logo.